Living in a hurricane-prone area means your home needs strong protection. When storms hit, broken windows or doors can cause serious damage. That’s why many homeowners look for ways to keep their homes safe during severe weather. Two common options are hurricane-proof windows and doors or installing hurricane shutters. Both are designed to protect your home from strong winds and flying debris, but they work differently. Some people prefer the built-in strength of impact-resistant windows, while others choose shutters for their lower cost.
This blog will explore each option offered, how they compare, and which one might be better for your needs.
Hurricane-Proof Windows and Doors
Hurricane-proof windows and doors are specially made to protect your home during strong storms. They are built using strong materials like laminated or tempered glass, which can handle high winds and flying objects. [1]
How do they function during hurricanes?
- Laminated glass has dual layers of glass with a strong plastic layer in between. Even if it cracks, the pieces stick together instead of breaking apart.
- Reinforced frames made of metal or strong vinyl help keep the windows and doors in place during high pressure.
- No need to cover them before a storm – they offer protection 24/7.
Long-term Benefits
These windows and doors are tested to handle hurricane-force winds and impacts. They also help with:
- Security: Harder to break in, even for burglars.
- Noise reduction: Keeps outside noise down.
- Energy savings: Helps keep your home cool in summer and warm in winter.
- UV protection: Blocks harmful sun rays that can fade furniture.
Though they cost more than regular windows, they are cost-efficient over time by lowering energy bills and possibly reducing home insurance costs. If you want strong, always-ready protection, hurricane-proof windows and doors are a smart choice.
Hurricane Shutters
Hurricane shutters are coverings installed over your windows and sometimes doors to protect them during a storm. They act like shields to stop flying debris, strong winds, and rain from breaking your glass and damaging your home. Unlike hurricane-proof windows and doors, shutters are used only when a storm is coming and need to be closed or installed in advance. [2]
Why Use Hurricane Shutters?
Hurricane shutters are a popular choice because:
- They cost less than hurricane-proof windows and doors.
- They come in many styles and sizes.
- They can be added to most homes, even older ones.
Types of Hurricane Shutters
Here are the most common types:
- Accordion Shutters: These fold like an accordion and stay attached to the sides of your windows. You just pull them closed when needed.
- Roll-Down Shutters: These roll down from a box above your window, either manually or with a motor.
- Storm Panels: These are metal or plastic panels that you install before a storm and remove after.
- Bahama Shutters: Hinged at the top and provide shade when not in use. Easy to close before a storm.
- Colonial Shutters: Decorative and functional. They swing shut from the sides of the window.
Pros of Hurricane Shutters
- More affordable than replacing windows.
- Protects regular glass from breaking.
- Adds an extra layer of security.
- Some styles can improve your home’s look.
Things to Keep in Mind
- You must close or install them before each storm.
- Some types are heavy and may need more than one person to set up.
- May not insulate or reduce noise like hurricane-proof windows and doors.
Home Value, Building Codes & Insurance Considerations
When deciding between hurricane-proof windows and doors and shutters, it’s important to think about how each option affects your home’s value, meets building rules, and impacts your insurance costs.
Home Value
Installing hurricane-proof windows and doors can increase your home’s value. Many buyers see them as a smart investment because they offer strong protection all year round. These windows and doors look modern and improve your home’s curb appeal.
On the other hand, hurricane shutters may not add as much value. Some types of shutters can change the appearance of your home, which not everyone likes. However, if you choose stylish shutters that match your house, they can still add some value.
Building Codes
In many hurricane-prone areas, local laws require homes to have protection for windows and doors. For example, Florida has strict building codes to reduce storm damage. Both hurricane-proof windows and doors and certified shutters usually meet these codes. Before making a choice, check your local building rules to ensure your protection option is approved.
Insurance Considerations
Many insurance companies offer discounts on installing hurricane-proof windows and doors because they reduce damage risk. These savings can help compensate for the higher upfront cost. Shutters may also qualify for discounts, but usually less than impact windows and doors.
Head-to-Head Comparison: Effectiveness, Cost, and Convenience
Here is a comparison between hurricane-proof windows and doors and hurricane shutters.
| Feature | Hurricane-Proof Windows and Doors | Hurricane Shutters |
| Protection Level | Strong, built-in protection that works all the time | Good protection, but it depends on the shutter type and setup |
| Ease of Use | No action needed – always ready | Must be closed or installed before each storm |
| Cost | Higher upfront cost, but long-term value | Lower initial cost, may need replacement over time |
| Maintenance | Very little needed | Needs regular checks for rust or damage |
| Looks | Modern and clean appearance | Some styles may change how your home looks |
| Extra Benefits | Energy-saving, blocks UV rays, reduces noise | Mostly storm protection only |
| Insurance Discounts | Often qualifies for higher discounts | May qualify, but depends on the type and location |
Which One Is Right for You? Key Considerations
Deciding between hurricane-proof windows and doors and hurricane shutters comes down to what matters most to you. Here’s a quick look at the main benefits: [3]
Cost
Impact windows and doors need a bigger investment upfront, but are durable and low maintenance. Shutters are easier on the wallet initially, but might need repairs or replacement over time.
Ease of Use
Windows and doors made for hurricanes stay strong all the time, no extra steps needed. Shutters require you to install or close them every time a storm approaches.
Level of Protection
Hurricane-proof windows and doors give solid, permanent defence against wind and flying debris. Shutters protect well, too, but only if they’re properly set up.
Appearance
Impact windows and doors keep your home’s look sleek and modern. Shutters can sometimes change your home’s style, though some designs blend in nicely.
Energy Efficiency
Hurricane-proof windows and doors help keep your home cooler in summer and warmer in winter, saving on energy bills. Shutters mainly protect during storms and don’t improve insulation.
Insurance Savings
Many insurance companies reward impact windows and doors with better discounts. Shutters may offer some savings, but usually less.
Conclusion
Choosing between hurricane-proof windows and doors and hurricane shutters depends on your budget, convenience, and protection needs. Impact windows and doors offer strong, always-on defence, improve home value, and save on energy and insurance costs. Shutters provide good storm protection at a lower initial price but need setup before storms and may affect your home’s look. Consider how often storms occur, your willingness to prepare, and local building codes before deciding. The right choice keeps your home safe and gives you peace of mind during hurricane season.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, hurricane windows or shutters?
Hurricane windows offer constant, built-in protection without setup, while shutters are cheaper but need to be installed before storms. The better choice depends on your budget and convenience.
What are the disadvantages of hurricane shutters?
Shutters require time and effort to close before storms, may affect your home’s appearance, and need regular maintenance to stay in good condition.
What is the best window protection for hurricanes?
Impact-resistant hurricane-proof windows and doors are the best because they provide strong, permanent protection and don’t need extra work during storms.
Do shutters protect against hurricanes?
Yes, shutters protect windows from flying debris and strong winds, but only if properly installed before a hurricane.
References
[1] https://www.marvin.com/blog/what-is-hurricane-impact-glass
[2] https://www.stormsmart.com/faqs/hurricane-shutters/what-are-hurricane-shutters/
[3] https://lashome.com/impact-resistant-windows-vs-hurricane-shutters/